No alternative to Alliance, says Alden

(CNS): Claiming there was no alternative government line-up to the Progressive Alliance, the outgoing premier, Alden McLaughlinAlden McLaughlin (PPM): Red Bay MP, Premier, Minister of International Trade, Investment, Aviation and Maritime Affairs (MITIAMA). Biography: McLaughlin has been a member of the... More, urged Cayman to vote for his platform of candidates, as he closed a rally on Saturday evening to launch the manifesto that represents the PPM’s plan for a new Alliance government.

The MP for Red Bay and the new party chairman pushed the message that none of the other candidates were able to deliver on any promises they might make to voters because they had no formalised political allies. He stressed that politics is all about “we” and not “I”, and said that any hastily pulled together government of independents on 15 April wouldn’t last.

Claiming the PPM-led Alliance was the only group with a plan, he said they were also the only candidates in a position to actually execute it because the others had not formed any structured alliances that could pose an alternative government and enable any of them to get a policy agenda through.

However, there are expectations that there will indeed be a clear line-up for a potential alternative government, the ‘coalition of the willing’, before voters go to the polls on Election Day, as most of the challengers with a serious chance of ousting an incumbent recognise the need to ensure that voters can see viable option to the status quo.

Reflecting on his own experience in 2000, when he was first elected as an independent and supported a coalition that fell apart after just one year, McLaughlin said he had lived through many attempts to put governments together. But he said ministers all run off in different directions when policies are not discussed and agreed on beforehand.

He said that after the 2017 election, it was “a mad scramble” because the ProgressivesThe People's Progressive Movement (PPM), also known as the Progressives, was founded in 2002 in response to the launch in 2001 of the United Democratic... More had only secured seven seats and at least ten are needed to govern.

Missing the point that the electorate had rejected the party he had led, having voted for twelve people who did not share the platform, McLaughlin nevertheless used that result and the current health crisis as justification for why the country should this time around vote for all of the people on the PPM platform and not just a few.

“We are in crucial times,” he said, adding that the coalition government he had led had only managed to navigate the pandemic successfully because of the money it had in the bank. But he warned that cash would not last forever and the next administration would be faced with the task of handling the continuing pandemic as well as how to keep business going and collect government revenue.

“We need every single member of this alliance to form the next government,” he said, as he urged voters to reject their favourite candidates if they were running against anyone in the Alliance.

Singling out Austin Harris, McLaughlin urged people to vote for him, saying he was the Alliance candidate in Prospect because the ProgressivesThe People's Progressive Movement (PPM), also known as the Progressives, was founded in 2002 in response to the launch in 2001 of the United Democratic... More were not fielding their own candidate in that constituency but were supporting the former radio talk-show host.

Harris, who emceed the evening, wore a PPM t-shirt under his regular shirt but never quite declared his full allegiance to the party that he wholeheartedly praised throughout the night.

McLaughlin hammered home the message to voters that they must only vote for Alliance and PPM candidates, putting the last nail in the coffin of his long friendship with Wayne PantonWayne Panton: Candidate for Newlands. He was Minister for Financial Services, Commerce and Environment (2013-2017). Biography: Panton successfully ran as a PPM candidate for one... More as he urged people to vote for Alva SuckooAlva Suckoo: Newlands MP Deputy Leader of the Opposition. Political Career: • Deputy Leader of the Opposition- May 2017-Present• Elected Member of the district of... More, the incumbent in Newlands, where Panton is running.

This endorsement was made despite the fact that Panton was once the main financier of the PPM campaigns and a founding member of the ProgressivesThe People's Progressive Movement (PPM), also known as the Progressives, was founded in 2002 in response to the launch in 2001 of the United Democratic... More, and even though McLaughlin has spent four years criticising the performance of Suckoo, the former deputy leader of the opposition.

McLaughlin also said Dwayne SeymourDwayne Seymour (IND): Bodden Town East MLA, Minister of Health, Environment, Culture and Housing. Biography: Seymour was first elected to the Legislative Assembly in 2009... More was “progressively becoming a Progressive” and was running on the Alliance ticket in Bodden Town East. He said he needed him as well as Vincent Frederick, a candidate for Bodden Town West.

However, Frederick is the clear underdog in the race against the independent incumbent Chris SaundersChristopher Saunders: Incumbent for Bodden Town West. Biography: Saunders is a certified Public Accountant and has held senior positions within the banking, telecommunications and financial... More, who will be one of the main contenders for a Cabinet job if the ‘coalition of the willing’ has a greater number of candidates than the Alliance. Seymour’s return is also far from certain, as he won a four-way race in 2017 with one of the smallest majorities that year.

This time Seymour is in a head-to-head battle with Osbourne BoddenOsbourne Bodden: Candidate for Bodden Town East. Biography: Bodden served two terms in government under the People’s Progressive Movement (PPM), first as a backbencher (2005-2009)... More, a former PPM Cabinet member who is running on the ‘Community Creates Country’ ticket with Panton and Heather BoddenHeather Bodden: Candidate for Savannah. She currently manages Wayne Panton's Savannah/Newlands Community office. Biography: Bodden served as a representative for Bodden Town from 1995 until... More, a candidate in Savannah.

“We cannot allow this to slip away from us,” McLaughlin said.

But after outlining the concept of a strong alliance and what he implied was a government in waiting, he undermined the entire position by saying that after the election the Alliance might still welcome more candidates, opening the door to other candidates in advance of the post-election horsetrading that he derided.

“As long as you believe in our cause and what we are trying to do… you are welcome aboard. I am not suggesting that people can’t come to us after the elections,” he said.

This raises the question of the return of McKeeva BushMcKeeva Bush (CDP), West Bay West MLA Speaker of the LA, Leader of the Cayman Democratic Party. Biography: Bush is the longest serving member and... More to a PPM-led government after the election if, as was the case in 2017, the party and its coalition members do not win the required ten seats.

McLaughlin has distanced himself from Bush and, with the exception of his near mea culpa moment on the hustings on behalf of Joey HewJoey Hew (PPM): George Town North MLA, Minister of Commerce, Planning, Infrastructure. Biography: Hew has been a member of the Legislative Assembly since 2013, when... More, he has avoided mentioning his one-time political nemesis.

He called early elections because of Bush’s refusal to resign from his position of speaker following his arrest and subsequent conviction for beating up a woman at a local bar.

But notably, McLaughlin failed to force Bush out of the job and the PPM has not fielded any party or Alliance candidates against him or his running mates, Capt. Eugene Ebanks and Rolston Anglin.

Nor has anyone in the ProgressivesThe People's Progressive Movement (PPM), also known as the Progressives, was founded in 2002 in response to the launch in 2001 of the United Democratic... More offered support to Mario EbanksMario Ebanks: Candidate for West Bay West. Chief Human Resources Officer at the Cayman Islands Airports Authority. Biography: • Eighth generation Caymanian, with great-grandparents from... More, an increasingly competitive challenger for Bush’s West Bay West seat, even though the incumbent has until now been seen as immovable and despite Ebanks’ previous support for the PPM.

And while Anglin has not made any indication that he supports the Alliance, Eugene Ebanks has fully committed to his support of the coalition that he had served in. During his appearance on the Chamber of Commerce Candidates Forum, he said he would be happy to serve again.