Hardware store owner re-appointed CPA chair
(CNS): The Cabinet has re-appointed A. L. Thompson, the owner of Cayman’s largest hardware store, to chair the Central Planning Authority for another three years. Despite ongoing concerns from the Office of the Auditor General and across the community about the potential conflicts for this particular board, the Cabinet has also re-appointed Robert Watler, the owner of a leading local construction firm, as the deputy.
Most of the existing members have been re-appointed, with just three new faces: Jaron Leslie, a lawyer with Harneys; Roland Bodden, a surveyor; and the former manager of the National Trust, Christina McTaggart-Pineda.
The CPA has faced significant criticism because the majority of its members are connected in some way to the development and construction sector. The prevailing public opinion has been that the membership is always inclined towards granting planning permission because the members stand to benefit directly or indirectly from almost every project approved by the authority.
The previous auditor general had raised concerns about the CPA membership and its bias towards development and had urged the government, when reappointing the board, to include members with environmental experience.
But once again, that advice has been ignored and the membership has been largely re-appointed. McTaggart-Pineda represents the first appointment of anyone with environmental credentials but is the only person with that experience, as well as being the only woman on the board among the non-executive appointments of twelve men.
The current auditor general, Sue Winspear, used the CPA as a case study in her recent report, “Fighting Corruption in the Cayman Islands”, to illustrate the potential vulnerabilities within government to corruption or perceptions of it.
During a recent Public Accounts Committee meeting, opposition MLA Chris Saunders (BTW) said about the CPA that “just about everybody sitting on that board is conflicted”.
At the same meeting the chief officer in the planning ministry had said that the authority was due to be reappointed this summer and warned that there were no guarantees that the Cabinet would take on-board the concerns about the membership and make any of the recommended changes.
In addition, although the board chair had said that members’ interests would be made public, the provisions on the planning website for this information remains blank.
CNS news is free to read but not free to produce. Please consider supporting independent journalism in the Cayman Islands.
Category: development, Local News, Politics
How long has Mr. Thompson been chairman of the CPA? As far as I can remember, from the early eighties. (Not sure if he was replaced in between.). It should be limited to two to three years.
I know the island is small and therefore there will always be someone who is family to someone but when you actually own the largest building supplying company on the island and is the chairman of the CPA, surely they would want to remove even the the perception of nepotism, cronyism, favouritism and any other “ism” you can think of.
But Alden got upset when Legge said “corruption” was so common here that Caymanians don’t even recognise it as corruption. He didn’t say all Caymanians were corrupt as Alden incorrectly claimed.
That’s crazy! That’s like if you were a really stupid president of the United States and had hotels (that your daddy gave you) and when people wanted something, they stayed in your hotels when they came to town to talk to you.
Nothing to see here. Just rich people running the world the way they want.
Very diverse. Apparently having Mr. in your name is a prerequisite.
It is for men
Men men men men
Men men men men
Throw the rubbers overboard
There’s nobody here but men.
Let’s face it nothing will ever change if we keep doing the same things over and over. Big developments will continue under the pretense Caymanians will benefit from these over priced projects. Caymanians will always be a second class citizen and be a dependent on the government. Whilst I appreciate some Caymanians have benefited from this so called progress but the majority will always be behind the 8 ball when we continue to accept these types of decisions that are continued to made by our leaders.
This is Cayman politics at it’s best, ignoring informed advice from a qualified and independent expatriate expert (the Auditor General) and continuing with that pervasive Caymanian canker of cronyism.
Say it like it is : Methinks you are more concerned that Caymanians are getting reappointed and not expats.From the tone of your post I suspect that had it been a competent Caymanian expert ( Auditor General) giving the advice regarding a board made of expats, then you would be questioning the competency of the Caymanian rather than the cronyism of the expats.
8.53pm Your “thinks” are totally out of court. It’ s nothing to do with the nationality of the CPA appointees, it’s conflict of interest and cronyism that’s the problem. This is a small island which encourages internal corruption. Have you considered why your own government has always employed an expatriate as the public service watchdog?.
7:52 am a wa you talking bout. We na hire Dem Hingland de ands dat oversite, so talk wa ya know iah!
Stupid is…stupid does.
The WPB and most of the other similar oversight bodies have been run like this for decades. Why would anyone try to change things?
Kris Bergstrom is a great guy, not all of them need to be bunched in with the baddies.
What line of business is his Edgewater company in again?
Maybe his family company but he’s a pilot for Cayman Airways.
In his off time he is a pilot. In his on time, he runs a contracting business.
That well may be the case, but we’re talking about perception here.
We need more development quickly!
Yes, yes, 12:15 bring on those 50 storey buildings so we can have permanent gridlock on weekdays on Grand Cayman.
Bathrooms! Bathrooms! Get your lovely bathrooms! Free planning permission included with every bathroom….
Another affirmation of why this bunch will never enact the Standards for Public Life law. Keep electing Alden, McKeeva and their lackeys like Joey and we going to get worse than this.
And if Martin Roper ever utters the words ‘good governance’ again, he should choke. Two successive Auditor Generals that his office has appointed have said that this is a disgraceful situation and not one word from either Governor. Shameful
This just clears the way for Dart and McKeewa’s 50 story catastrophe.
I hope its over 100. If you’re going to do it, do it right
Don’t forget to rename Grand Cayman to Freak’s Island thereafter.
But…it is not going to be built. Too freakish for a 2 x 4 rock. No professional in their right mind would even touch it. They might entertain the idea, but wouldn’t proceed further.
Building a skyscraper in a heavily populated area would skyrocket Construction insurance premiums.
Headlines:
* Hurricane Irma: High winds cause cranes to collapse in Miami
* Miami’s Tower Construction Cranes Pose ‘Potential Danger’ During Hurricane
* Booming Miami is littered with tower cranes not built to withstand a massive hurricane
* Miami’s Tower Cranes Can’t Handle a Cat 5 Hurricane; Officials Send Warning to High-Rise Residents
* Florida’s construction cranes were designed to withstand Irma. Some did not.
Cranes take time to be dismantled, and the process also calls for blocking traffic on city streets. It takes five to six days per crane, and they can be up to 900 feet tall and include 10,000-pound counterweights. Those counterweights could pose a grave threat if any of the cranes are unable to withstand wind and flying debris.
FYI: There are two basic types of construction defects: defects that occur during the design of a home or building, and defects that occur during the building phase. As a general principle, an architect or engineer is usually responsible for defects in the design of a construction project. A builder, usually a contractor or subcontractor, is usually responsible for defects caused by a failure to conduct work according to design specifications.
So ‘no professional in their right mind would touch it’ and ‘Miami is littered with’ such projects. As is every Asian city regularly hit by cyclones. Make your mind up, or are all those skyscrapers built by enthusiastic amateurs?
Shame on Joey Hew …. appointing his friends… he as Minister in Charge of Planning can make recommendations to make changes..but why should he elections around the counter … I’m sure the People at the Ministry just went along they did nothing…
Business as usual! Cheers to the Unity Team and all there cronies.
Good Job Joey!!
Shut up twins!
Joey isn’t the minister responsible.
Yes, he is. He takes the Cabinet paper.
And why is it that you cannot even conceive of the possibility that AL T is a very good Chair who has the country’s interest at heart and in any event cannot make any decisions alone but rather he has other capable Cayman’s alongside him considering the submissions.
One word. Perception.
More like assumption in this case. And jealousy it seems.
No perception. I know Al T very well and he’s a nice guy, but the overwhelming public perception is that he stands to benefit from any permissions granted. That perception should be removed and I am sure in any country with properly adopted Standards in Public Life legislation he would not be the Chairman of the Planning Authority.
Wow this guy loves all these great pro-development members. Bet he is a Unity person as well
His building supply store is a commercial recipient, and that puts him in direct conflict of interest with his duties as Chair of planning.
One word.
CONFLICTED.
Lol. Really ??
Simply case, they demand 5 foot wall for public beach to control access from the road but smith barcadere? Wait and see. If they require it there as well then it was applied fairly. It is a bit concerning you don’t see the concern. He has also purchased at Fin which strangely has numerous approved variants to its plans. Such as set backs, from roads and waterfront. Where there is smoke….
A Minister decides the content of a Cabinet paper – not the “people at the ministry”
Chicken and chips for everyone!
the whole cpa should consist of qualifed expats.
Just stick an auditor in there who will ask questions. An auditor by profession is a skeptic. There are over 1300 accountants on the island many of whom are auditors.
Good point Chris. There is a lawyer on board no why ot an auditor. An auditor is likely to spot vested interests and conflicts of board members which have been prevalent over the years.
You have answered your own question
What would an auditor know about proper planning?
What would a Board filled of vested interests know about anyway?
The OAG is commenting on the process not planning matters.
What do the current board members know about planning? Most of them are not even versed in the Planning Laws or Regulations!
Ask Dan and Jude Scott who built a couple of nice houses.
There are many auditors here who would love to help. Good job Chris is retired.
Please keep him there talk about conflicts 🤔
What a stupid and assenine remark which no reader could possibly understand. Alcohol must be responsible.
an evil empire. but alwways going to happen in such a small place like cayman…especially when half the population has zero democratic rights.
McKeeva reigns!
God forbid that ever happens again 7.31.
It continues to this day, seriously who do you think holds the power in government? Without Mac there is no Government one way or another.
things that make you go hmmm…
Does this surprise anyone?
definition of madness…voting same people in the house and expect change? caymanians…you are the problem…not the career politicians???
6:21pm, you are right. Cayman Isl.real have some fool fool voters.
Another ummm – Mr. Ashton Bodden from all the years I have known him – he was a civil servant and now is retired. I do not recall his involvement with any sort of construction firm or development. I could be wrong, if so I am sure someone will make me know thru this forum.
Mr. Ashton does a great job leading the DCB, hopefully he does any equally great job at the CPA.
Thank you for your continued service to our communities Mr. Ashton.
Signed,
Brac Resident who has property on all three of our beloved islands.
Mr. Ashton is a good person, but in this context about as useful as Moses; both completely out of their depth.
Not sure how Mo$e$ name came up in this conversation. Totally disagree with him being out of depth. While the almighty dollar may be an incentive for Mo$e$, he has done more for developing Cayman Brac/Little Cayman than any other Caymanian.
And not sure how Mr. Ashton is out of depth? Please provide some more insight on this, am curious – thanks.
Moses has done more than Linton Tibbetts? Really?!
Point taken, but Mr. Linton (RIP) isn’t here anymore. Mo$e$ still here and still trying to do stuff
7,:36 pm, you don’t really know him
Isn’t he Stran’s father???
Okay now there is the perception thing with Mr. Ashton – thanks finally got it!
Ummmm. Christina doesn’t have development ties, she’s the Trust. What is the problem?
She quit the trust long time.
Maybe the New National Trust leader should be on this board and why not the Chairman, he is s really useful architect. These people are not afraid of speaking out.
The one on record as the architect of the Beach Bay monstrosity?
And another one who hasnt read the planning regulatuons or laws or building codes….